Study notes

Matthew 17

Introducing MatthewWho wrote it, when, why, and what to look for as you read

16:28–17:13 Section

Jesus took his three most trusted disciples up a mountain.

Peter, James and John saw Jesus’ glory as the Son of Man.

The change in his face and clothes showed them something. It showed them Jesus’ power and authority in the heavenly world.

Then Moses and Elijah both appeared. Their presence on the mountain was a sign. It was a sign that everything from Israel’s past led to Jesus.

Jesus is God’s Son. His work accomplishes all of God’s purposes.

Jesus told the three disciples not to tell others what they had seen on the mountain. They could only talk about it after Jesus was raised from the dead. That is when they would be able to understand what they had seen.

17:1

  • Peter, James, and John later went with Jesus to Gethsemane (Matthew 26:37; 2 Peter 1:16–19).

  • We cannot know the exact location of this high mountain. The traditional site, Mount Tabor, is about 580 meters high (1,900 feet). It is not on the way if leaving from Caesarea Philippi (Matthew 16:13) to go to Capernaum (17:24).

    Mount Hermon is another option. It is about 2,800 meters high (9,200 feet) and located in Syria, about sixty-four kilometers (forty miles) north of Capernaum. Yet, it is improbable that “scribes” (Mark 9:14) would have gathered at the base of a mountain in non-Jewish territory. A likely location is Mount Meron, about 1,220 meters high (4,000 feet). It is located between Caesarea Philippi and Capernaum.

17:3

Moses represents the law, and Elijah represents the prophets. They appeared as witnesses to Christ. Their presence showed that Jesus, the Son of God, fulfills everything written in the law and the prophets (see Matthew 5:17–20; 11:2–6; 12:28).

17:4

Three shelters (Or three tabernacles): Peter probably thought the kingdom of heaven was about to arrive in full glory (compare Acts 1:6). He wanted to remember the moment by building shelters.

17:9

People could not fully understand Jesus until he completed his work, especially his death and resurrection.

17:10–13

Elijah’s appearance made the disciples ask about the belief that Elijah must return before the Messiah comes (see Malachi 4:5–6). Jesus pointed to John the Baptist as the one who fulfilled that role. In doing so, he reminded them of the surprising truth that the Messiah must suffer, just as John, his forerunner, had also suffered (Matthew 14:3–12).

17:14–27 Section

The disciples were struggling. They had been looking for a messiah who would destroy the Romans.

The disciples had seen Jesus’ power over evil spiritual beings. So they believed he could make the nation of Israel strong again. They thought he would do this with force and power.

But when they tried to act based on this kind of faith, they failed. Jesus was troubled and concerned. He didn’t want them to do God’s work using force or their own strength. He wanted them to completely trust God. He wanted them to depend fully on God’s power to accomplish what God wanted done.

God can do anything. Through a fish he provided the money the disciples needed to pay their taxes.

Yet Jesus said that he would be killed. Death was part of how he would serve God and others. The disciples were confused and sad. This was a time of testing (test) for them.

17:17

O unbelieving and perverse generation: This phrase often describes moral corruption (see Deuteronomy 32:5, 19–22). Jesus usually directed this exclamation at unbelieving Jewish crowds or leaders who refused to recognize God's presence in him (see Matthew 12:39). But here the phrase sharply criticizes his disciples for not trusting in Jesus and his power to save and heal.

17:20

  • Here, the phrase so little faith means the same as no faith.

  • faith the size of a mustard seed: This suggests that even a tiny amount of faith can help the disciples achieve great things (Hebrews 21:21; compare 1 Corinthians 13:2). It also suggests that if they let their faith increase (see Matthew 13:31–32), they could act with strong belief.

  • "Moving mountains" is a saying that means overcoming obstacles and achieving God's goals (Isaiah 40:4; 49:11; 54:10; 1 Corinthians 13:2).

17:24

  • Every adult citizen of Israel had to pay the temple tax of one-half shekel. This was a coin weighing 4 grams. In the time of Jesus, priests and some rabbis did not pay this tax.

  • Peter spoke on behalf of the twelve apostles (see Matthew 10:2).

17:25–26

As an obedient Jew, Jesus would have paid the tax every year, and he did pay it. The lesson Jesus wanted to teach was that as God's Son, he is greater than the temple (Matthew 12:5–6). By this, he showed that a decisive break with the temple was coming (see 16:18–19; 21:33–46).

Verse notes: Adapted by Mission Mutual (Aquifer Open Study Notes) from Tyndale Open Study Notes © 2023 Tyndale House Publishers. CC BY-SA 4.0. Section notes: Biblica Study Notes © 2023 Biblica, Inc. CC BY-SA 4.0, via BibleAquifer. About the sources